You Can’t Creat a Classic Without Laying a Few Eggs

When we discuss the greatest band in rock history, we tend to focus on the triumphs—the revolutionary albums, the screaming fans, the cultural earthquakes. But what makes The Beatles truly fascinating is that even they, with all their genius, occasionally laid an egg. Who doesn’t? For every “A Day in the Life,” there’s a “Wild Honey Pie.” For every “Strawberry Fields Forever,” there’s a “Revolution 9.” Or a “Mr. Moonight.” 🎸

Because music appreciation is subjective, there’s no single “official” list of their best and worst work. But here is a deep analysis aggregated from professional critics, fan polls, streaming analytics (play counts and skip rates on Spotify and Apple Music), and the band members’ own testimonies from interviews, the Anthology series, and Mark Lewisohn’s recording session documentation. And I’ve sprinkled in my own opinions here and there. 📊

The Good: Five Songs Acknowledged as Their Best

1. A Day in the Life

Nearly universally ranked as The Beatles’ greatest achievement, this Sgt. Pepper closer is praised for its ambitious structure, orchestral crescendos, and profound lyricism drawn from Lennon and McCartney at their creative peak. Rolling Stone’s “100 Greatest Beatles Songs” consistently places it at No. 1, and for good reason. John worries about holes in the road, while Paul gets startled by his alarm clock, all building to that apocalyptic orchestral climax and final piano chord. 🎹

2. Strawberry Fields Forever

Has there ever been a more perfect marriage of tripped-out psychedelia with pure, perfect pop? This Lennon masterpiece appears in the top three of virtually every critical ranking. Pitchfork and Vulture, which tend to favor the “art-rock” side of the band, consistently champion this as peak Beatles. Originally recorded during the Sgt. Pepper sessions, George Martin later removed it from the album to release it as a double A-side with “Penny Lane”—a marketing misstep, perhaps, but one that only added to the song’s mystique. 🍓

3. In My Life

It’s maybe impossible to say that any one Beatles song is their best, but it’s hard to argue against “In My Life.” Helped along by George Martin’s sped-up piano solo, it’s a gorgeous, heartbreaking, and nostalgic meditation on memory and loss. What’s remarkable is that Lennon was only 24 when he wrote it, transforming a long poem about riding a bus through Liverpool into this perfectly realized reflection. “It was the first song I wrote that was consciously about my life,” John said. “I think this was my first major piece of work.” 💭

4. Yesterday

One of the most covered songs in music history (over 2,000 versions), “Yesterday” remains what Entertainment Weekly calls “the untouchable gold standard” for The Beatles’ melodic legacy. McCartney’s simple, emotional ballad—recorded with just acoustic guitar and string quartet—proves the band didn’t need complexity to achieve greatness. Sometimes less is more. Though some critics now find it mawkish and overplayed, its enduring popularity is undeniable. By 2012, the BBC calculated that “Yesterday” had generated some £19.5 million in royalty payments. 💰 Not bad for a song Paul thought up while he was sleeping.

5. Hey Jude

The Beatles’ best-selling UK single and the song that launched a billion wobble-headed “Na-na-na-naaaa!”s. This seven-minute epic starts as Paul’s consolation to John’s son Julian during his parents’ divorce and builds to one of rock’s most iconic singalong endings. It was the first Beatles song recorded on then-state-of-the-art eight-track equipment and remains a massive moment during McCartney’s solo shows. 🎤

Honorable mentions that appear across multiple “best of” lists: “Something,” “Let It Be,” “Help!,” “Eleanor Rigby,” “Come Together” ✨

A footnote: The Beatles’ early up-tempo songs are often the favorites of Baby Boomers (like me) who were alive in 1964 and grew up experiencing the band in real time, album by album. If you tried telling me that “I Want to Hold Your Hand” and “I Saw Her Standing There” aren’t two of the best pop songs ever, I’d tell you to get your ears examined 🤣.

The Bad and Ugly: Five Songs Most Frequently Criticized

The “worst” list is harder to track. So this data comes from Reddit survivor polls (where thousands of fans vote off their least favorite tracks), streaming skip-rate data, and—most tellingly—the band members’ own commentary. 🗣️

1. Revolution 9

Eight minutes of avant-garde sound collage that tops almost every “worst Beatles songs” list. It’s not that John Lennon’s experimental piece is totally terrible—in its jarring, abrasive way, it’s “art” on the most outré level. It just doesn’t belong on a Beatles record, not even one as wildly uneven as the White Album. On Reddit’s “Survivor” polls, where thousands of fans vote off their least favorite tracks one by one, “Revolution 9” is almost always the first to be eliminated. 🎨

2. Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da

Appearing on the White Album, this track features a plodding beat, jarring piano, and obnoxious hand claps. Sure, millions of listeners love this catchy song, but Lennon openly and vocally detested it, calling it “granny music shit.” According to Beatles biographer Mark Lewisohn, McCartney recorded the song over 60 times until he was happy with it, which drove Lennon (among other people) insane. To get the track finished, out of sheer frustration, Lennon went to the rooftop of the studio to smoke a joint, then stormed back in to pound out the “mock music-hall” intro that we hear on the record today. By showing McCartney how silly the granny-music stuff was when played fast, Lennon accidentally gave the song the energy it needed. 🎹

3. Wild Honey Pie

A McCartney solo experiment lasting barely over a minute, this White Album track is dismissed across multiple publications as pointless filler. It’s more an interlude than a song—a product of the sprawl that characterized the White Album sessions. On any other record, this would have been scrapped. Even the most devoted Beatles fans struggle to defend it (or even recall it), and it shows some of the lowest play counts on streaming platforms. 🍯

4. Maxwell’s Silver Hammer

Here’s where the band members’ own testimony becomes crucial. In 2008, Ringo said bluntly: “The worst session ever was ‘Maxwell’s Silver Hammer’. It was the worst track we ever had to record. It went on for f**king weeks. I thought it was mad.” This assessment appears in interviews from the Anthology series and various biographies, including Lewisohn’s The Complete Beatles Recording Sessions, where both Ringo and George explicitly named it as their least favorite recording experience. McCartney’s murder-themed novelty song with its cutesy “Bang! Bang!” refrain tested everyone’s patience. 🔨 (Yet many listeners love this music-hall song.)

5. Yellow Submarine

McCartney said: “’Yellow Submarine’ is very simple but very different. It’s a fun song, a children’s song.” And that’s precisely the problem for many fans—it’s too childish, with an insufferably repetitive chorus that even Beatles devotees struggle to defend. While it became a massive hit and spawned an animated film, it’s one that even massive Beatles fans often cite as their least favorite, hating it for what one critic called its “childish goober sing-song style.” 🟡

Dishonorable mentions that appear frequently on “worst” lists: “Piggies,” “Mr. Moonlight” (which shows the highest skip rates on streaming platforms), “Don’t Pass Me By,” “Within You Without You” (highly divisive), and “Run For Your Life” (criticized for violent, misogynistic lyrics—(Lennon himself called it his “least favorite Beatles song” by 1973). ⚠️

The Takeaway

The Beatles’ genius wasn’t that they never failed—it’s that they failed so rarely while taking so many risks. Unlike almost every other successful band, they refused to do the same thing twice. For every eight-minute sound collage that fell flat, there was an eight-minute orchestral masterpiece that changed music forever. Even their worst songs have something historic going for them, whether it’s Ringo’s first songwriting credit or Paul’s ambitious (if misguided) studio experimentation. 🚀

As one critic noted: “If you ever doubt that The Beatles were the greatest band that ever existed, try ranking their songs. You’ll list well over a hundred tracks before you get to anything you wouldn’t call sublime, and hit 150 or so before anything verging on average appears.” 📈

That’s the mark of greatness—not perfection, but a ratio of triumph to failure that no other band has ever matched. 👑

Visit my Beatles Store: