Welcome to the lore of \u201cCarnival of Light,\u201d<\/strong> the Beatles track that nobody except Paul wants you to hear, that Paul has been trying to release for nearly 30 years, and that might actually be genuinely terrible. This is a story about competitive egos, avant-garde one-upmanship, and why, sometimes, archival material should stay buried.<\/p> \u201cCarnival of Light\u201d is nearly 14 minutes long and was recorded on January 5, 1967, right after the Beatles finished working on \u201cPenny Lane.\u201d Paul McCartney had been asked to contribute something to an art event at the Roundhouse Theatre in London, and he convinced his bandmates to spend ten minutes making what he later described as something in \u201cthe Stockhausen\/John Cage bracket.\u201d<\/p> According to Mark Lewisohn, reportedly the only journalist who\u2019s actually heard the full recording, here\u2019s what\u2019s on those four tracks:<\/p> Track one:<\/strong> distorted, hypnotic drum and organ sounds<\/p><\/li> Track two:<\/strong> distorted lead guitar<\/p><\/li> Track three:<\/strong> church organ, water gargling, and John and Paul \u201cscreaming dementedly and bawling aloud random phrases like \u2018Are you alright?\u2019 and \u2018Barcelona!\u2019\u201d<\/p><\/li> Track four:<\/strong> indescribable sound effects with heaps of echo and manic tambourine<\/p><\/li><\/ul> The piece ends with Paul asking in an echo-soaked voice, \u201cCan we hear it back now?\u201d 💀<\/p> No lyrics. There\u2019s no melody. At one point Paul plays a bit of \u201cFixing a Hole\u201d on piano, and at another point John shouts \u201cElectricity!\u201d There are Native American war cries, whistling, close-miked gasping, actual coughing, and fragments of studio conversation. Paul\u2019s instruction to his bandmates was simple: \u201cAll I want you to do is just wander around all the stuff, bang it, shout, play it, it doesn\u2019t need to make any sense.\u201d<\/p> Mission accomplished, Paul. It makes no sense whatsoever.<\/p> The beautiful irony: Paul created this piece for a specific event, and its publicity posters promised \u201cmusic composed by Paul McCartney.\u201d But none of the Beatles showed up for the big reveal. While the audience was shivering in a cold, cavernous former train depot, Paul and George were in the plush seats of the Royal Albert Hall watching the Four Tops. 🎭<\/p> The people who did hear it were, in the words of Paul\u2019s biographer Ian Peel, \u201ccomprehensively underwhelmed.\u201d The eyewitness verdict was unanimous and brutal:<\/p> The Organizer (David Vaughan):<\/strong> \u201cI don\u2019t think it was up to much.\u201d<\/p><\/li> The Performer (Daevid Allen):<\/strong> \u201cI dimly remember the sound collage because it was not particularly memorable.\u201d<\/p><\/li> The BBC Radiophonic expert (Brian Hodgson):<\/strong> \u201cIt was all rather a mess… There seemed to be no coherence to what was on the tape.\u201d<\/p><\/li><\/ul> It takes a special kind of failure to record a 14-minute Beatles track that people actually forget<\/em> while they are listening to it. 😬<\/p> Now we get to the heart of why this matters so much to Paul, and why he\u2019s spent decades trying to release a track that literally everyone who\u2019s heard it says is dreadful. It\u2019s because of John Lennon and \u201cRevolution 9.\u201d<\/p> In 1968, John and Yoko Ono created \u201cRevolution 9\u201d for the White Album<\/em>\u2014that eight-minute sound collage of tape loops and random noise. It became the definitive proof in the public\u2019s mind that John was the Beatles\u2019 resident revolutionary. But here is the historical twist: Paul had recorded \u201cCarnival,\u201d his own experimental freakout in January 1967\u2014a full eighteen months before John ever touched a tape loop for \u201cRevolution 9.\u201d<\/strong><\/p> While John was still living a relatively quiet life in the suburbs, Paul was the one hanging out with the London underground scene, attending Stockhausen lectures, and pushing the boundaries of what \u201cmusic\u201d could be. John actually used to mock the avant-garde, famously calling it \u201cFrench for bullshit.<\/em>\u201d<\/p> And yet, because \u201cRevolution 9\u201d was released to the world and \u201cCarnival of Light\u201d was buried in a vault, history remembers John as the \u201cweird\u201d Beatle. John got the avant-garde credit. John became the experimental innovator. And this drives Paul absolutely crazy. 😤<\/p> As Paul told Mark Lewisohn: \u201cI was getting interested in avant garde things… I never got known for being that way because John later superseded me, \u2018Oh, it must have been John who was the Stockhausen freak.\u2019 In actual fact it wasn\u2019t, it was me.\u201d<\/p> So \u201cCarnival of Light\u201d isn\u2019t just a 14-minute noise experiment. It\u2019s Paul\u2019s receipt. It\u2019s his evidence that he was the avant-garde Beatle before John ever met Yoko. The problem is that the receipt shows he purchased something nobody actually wants to hear.<\/p> Fast forward to 1996 and the development of the Anthology<\/em> project\u2014those three double albums of outtakes, demos, and rarities that let fans hear the Beatles\u2019 creative process. Paul sees his chance. He wants \u201cCarnival of Light\u201d included on Anthology 2<\/em>.<\/p> George Harrison, Ringo Starr, and Yoko Ono<\/strong> all said no. Vetoed. Rejected. Not happening. 🚫<\/p> Paul later recalled: \u201cThe guys didn\u2019t like the idea, like \u2018this is rubbish.\u2019\u201d George, who had his own avant-garde albums in the late \u201860s (Wonderwall Music<\/em> and Electronic Sound<\/em>), still didn\u2019t want \u201cCarnival of Light\u201d released. Paul joked that George would say \u201cavant-garde a clue\u201d about such things, but the reality is that George just thought it wasn\u2019t good enough.<\/p> Even George Martin,<\/strong> the Beatles\u2019 producer who was helping evaluate all the recordings for Anthology<\/em>, didn\u2019t think it should be released. After the original recording session ended in 1967, Martin had said: \u201cThis is ridiculous. We\u2019ve got to get our teeth into something constructive.\u201d Nearly thirty years later, his opinion hadn\u2019t changed.<\/p>What Even IS \u201cCarnival of Light\u201d?<\/h3>
The Roundhouse Disaster Nobody Talks About<\/h3>
The Paul vs. John Avant-Garde Championship Belt<\/h3>
The Anthology Vetoes That Broke Paul\u2019s Heart<\/h3>
![\"Buy](\"https:\/\/i0.wp.com\/substack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com\/public\/images\/2ceabdcf-d75f-4b9f-8039-97cdc187682b_500x354.jpeg?w=640&ssl=1\")
<\/figure>