
I'm a big fan of Amazon's book recommendations. For years, I've relied on them because they're the collective judgment of people like me -- people who have bought similar books.
So when Amazon asks me to consider a new book, I listen. In fact, I buy most of my new books this way. And believe me, I buy tons of books. Literally.
Sure, sometimes Amazon spits out a wacky recommendation. Like last year, when they asked me to buy a book about hysterectomies. Being a guy, I just wasn't interested. But hey, nothing's perfect, not even Amazon's computers.
Recently, though, I feel something has gone seriously wrong. What got my attention was this book recommendation I received in an Amazon e-mail last week:
As someone who has purchased or rated books by Robert A. Wilson, you might like to know that Mexico And Its Religion: With Incidents Of Travel In That Country During Parts Of Years 1861-64 And Historical Notices Of Events Connected With Places Visited is now available. You can order yours for just $34.95 by following the link below.
Mexico And Its Religion: With Incidents Of Travel In That Country During Parts Of Years 1861-64 And Historical Notices Of Events Connected With Places Visited
Huh? I've never bought or rated a book by Robert A. Wilson. In fact, I've never bought a book on Amazon by anyone named Wilson. And I've never bought a book about Mexico or religious history, either.
But here's what's really strange: Normally, Amazon recommends
new books. But this isn't a new book at all. In fact, it seems
this book isn't even being marketed by the publisher.
What am I talking about? Look at the book's
product page on Amazon. There's no cover image, excerpts, or even a description of the book. No reviews, no page count, no blurbs, nothing! Why not? My hunch is the publisher figures
it's so unlikely that anyone will buy this book, it's not worth the trouble. Even the publisher doesn't trust the book. But it's good enough for my Amazon recommendations?
What's going on? According to
this account, (thanks, Denny) the publisher is systematically "swiping copyrights." He says it's reprinting old books without even asking permission from copyright owners. Sounds like a great business model. You get your content free by scanning an old book. You use
print-on-demand publishing, so you have no printing costs. At least, no printing costs until some poor schmuck orders a copy.
But what really irks me is how Amazon is involved. How can I trust their recommendations anymore? Their whole value was unbiased recommendations based on other shoppers. Now it seems Amazon's recommendations aren't only advertising, they're random, irrelevant advertising. In a word, spam.
For all I know, this publisher is paying Amazon to send out zillions of these spam book recommendations, or perhaps Amazon has a stake in this outfit. I don't know. All I know is, something that was truly special about Amazon -- book recommendations based on what other people like me bought -- has been corrupted.
---------------
If you like my articles, click the orange button to subscribe:

Steve Weber is author of Plug Your Book! Online Book Marketing for Authors
Labels: Amazon recommendations, book recommendations, print on demand