Wednesday, April 25

Would you risk spamming your audience to get a few sales?

Online book marketing is a rough and tumble environment these days. Let's face it, bad behavior is rampant among authors, just like any other group -- it's easy to be rude and underhanded when you don't have to face people.

In some cases, the offending authors think they've done nothing wrong. In a Wall Street Journal column, author Mick Hager whines that many of his unsolicited e-mails weren't delivered for his Amazon Bestseller Campaign. As a result, the book reached an Amazon Sales Rank of only 5,000, and now his book is sliding right back to where it began, at the bottom of the barrel.

Mr. Hager calls his messages legitimate marketing, but I'm confident most of the recipients considered them spam. He admits he harvested the addresses from Web sites and claims this is legal.

Is it worth selling one or two dozen books if you gain a reputation as a spammer in the process? I don't think so.

E-mail isn't the only way authors are gaming the system, especially on Amazon.com, says author/publisher Aaron Shepard. "It's getting to be a real jungle on there," says Shepard, author of the self-publishing guide Aiming at Amazon. "Authors are spamming Amazon in a desperate effort to get their books noticed. Many don't even realize their behavior is inappropriate, because they have no experience in business. Others know but do it anyway, just because they can get away with it."

Here's the most common spamming techniques employed by authors, Shepard says:
  • Writing positive customer reviews of their own books under false names.
  • Soliciting positive reviews from friends and relatives who have no real interest in the book's subject and pretend to be objective.
  • Writing positive reviews of competitors' books but mentioning the reviewer's book to draw off sales.
  • Creating dozens of Listmania lists so that Amazon will display a book's cover whether or not it's relevant.
Authors face few consequences for spamming Amazon because the company doesn't outlaw many of the techniques, Shepard says. "In most cases, Amazon doesn't clearly prohibit them. Yes, the spirit of Amazon's guidelines does oppose these practices -- which is why Amazon can deal with them when reported. But Amazon could discourage such things much more effectively by just saying, 'Don't do this.'"

Instead, Amazon sometimes seems to actually encourage spam. Recently, for instance, it started allowing customer reviewers to link to other products from inside the reviews. "I don't know what they could be thinking," says Shepard. "You know just how this will be used. Authors will not only mention their own books, they'll link to them!"

If Amazon won't vigorously police its site, what's the answer? Well, Shepard has an idea: He's proposed a code of conduct for authors on the Internet.

Labels: ,

4 Comments:

Anonymous An honest author said...

This article has merit, and I found Aaron Shepard's points salient - except that he comes across as a complete hypocrite, as an investigation of HIS listmanias shows that he himself has been spamming Amazon with listmanias loaded to the gills with HIS books (always listed 2,3,4, and even 5 deep at the very top - never in the middle or end) in various questionable categories, and a few arguably correct ones. But the point is that he has been a busy boy, especially around Halloween 2005 when he slammed Amazon with tons of listmanias.

One has to wonder the quality of advice when dished out by the guilty party. I also wonder how long this comment will stay up.

4/28/2007  
Blogger Mark Rosenkranz said...

I am plugging the book White Male Privilege.

4/29/2007  
Blogger Steve Weber said...

Honest Author,

I think there's a good reason Shepard has dozens of Listmanias: He has dozens of books for sale on Amazon. He has 34 books available on Amazon and 30 Listmanias. That is altogether different from (for example) another author I know of who has one book listed on Amazon and has 20 Listmanias dedicated to that single book.

4/30/2007  
Anonymous An honest author replies said...

Nicely phrased Steve. So... while I agree that Mr. Shepard SHOULD actively promote his book (after all, who else will?) I personally found that *if* he is listing his books 3, 4, and 5 deep on Listmanias (at the TOP no less!) then it smacks a wee bit o' the forked tongue to whine about other authors. Sadly we all know that whatever the public is given access to will be abused and even occasionally ruined (public parks, public libraries, public bathrooms) by a few jerks.

That being said, I think Mr. Shepard should abstain from pointing fingers too vehemently if he is going to promote his books so vociferously. THAT being said, I do not think he is breaking any rules (I think I hear a moral or two creaking in protest of being bent, but no snapping of any rules by Mr. Shepard - and I did enjoy buying and reading his books).

So... LET HIM SELL! Sell your books! Plug away! Try to play nice, and can we dispense with the admonishment of mid-level moral offenses in favor of lambasting the hard-core rule breakers? Just some thought to chew on.

In the interests of full disclosure: I have also bought (and learned from) one of Steve's books, but am not an acquaintance of Mr. Weber.

5/03/2007  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home